Annotated Excerpt: THE BONE SHIPS by RJ Barker (Orbit)

BarkerRJ-TC1-BoneShipsUSToday, we have the honour of sharing an annotated excerpt from RJ Barker‘s highly-anticipated novel, The Bone Ships! The novel is due to be published by Orbit Books this week in both the UK and North America. First, though, here’s the synopsis:

A brilliantly imagined saga of honour, glory, and warfare…

Two nations at war. A prize beyond compare.

For generations, the fleets of the Hundred Isles have built their ships from the bones of ancient dragons to fight an endless war.

Then the dragons disappeared. But the battle for supremacy on the high seas persisted.

When the first dragon in centuries is spotted in far-off waters, both sides see a chance to shift the balance of power in their favour. Because whoever catches it will win not only glory, but the war.

Now, I’ll turn it over to RJ…


I, very naively, imagined that each book release would get easier. That you’d become more used to the process and more relaxed about people’s opinions. Especially for someone like me, who’s never really been overly concerned about what other people think. This should be easy, right?

This is not what happens.

But with the previous two books I at least had familiarity on my side. People were used to the world and the characters. Had I been sensible I’d have either stayed near it, maybe a first person murder mystery in another world, or maybe a fantasy adventure in another quasi medieval world because familiarity is a great thing.

Reader, I have been called many things in my life but sensible has never been one of them.

I wanted to do something different, so I did. This is a world built from the ground up with influences from the great ages of sail, and a society that I felt had some interesting ideas within it to play with.

There’s also the way words ebb and flow, and how the way something is said can work with what is being said to make a world come to life. I wanted to write something immersive, so it’s full of odd words and strange things. Some of the books I’ve loved the most do this, they throw you into a world and let you work it out. It might not work for everyone, but I find a huge amount of joy when things start coming together in my mind in a book and I move from “what is that?” to suddenly finding myself part of another world, and being lost in it.

It has been huge, huge fun to write.

It is absolutely terrifying to release.

So I’m thankful that Civilian Reader are giving me the chance to do an annotated version of the first chapter, a little taster with some of the ideas and concepts behind them explained as I go along. I hope you are intrigued.

— RJ


1: The Castaway

‘Give me your hat.’

They are not the sort of words that you expect to start a legend, but they were the first words he ever heard her say.

She said them to him, of course.

I wanted this to feel very different from the Wounded Kingdom books and not just because it’s written in third person rather than first person. I’m interested in the idea of stories and storytelling and that runs through these books. So this beginning was very deliberate, I wanted to give the reader the sort of feeling that, maybe this story is being told to you. You’ve sat down with some salty old sea dog and they’re telling you this story about these people. Maybe these people never even existed, who knows? Maybe it’s just an old, old story. But that was my thought, you (the reader) are not reading things as they happen, you’re being told a story and what better way to grab you then to tell you it’s about a legend? It’s also a presumption that you kind of know what’s going on and you know these people even though, of course, you don’t. There is not much hand holding in the Scattered Archipelago.

It was early. The scent of fish filled his nose and worked its way into his stomach, awakening the burgeoning nausea. His head ached and his hands trembled in a way that would only be stilled by the first cup of shipwine. Then the pain in his mind would fade as the thick liquid slithered down his gullet, warming his throat and guts. After the first cup would come the second, and with that would come the numbness that told him he was on the way to deadening his mind the way his body was dead, or waiting to be. Then there would be a third cup and then a fourth and then a fifth, and the day would be over and he would slip into darkness.

But the black ship in the quiet harbour would still sit at its rope. Its bones would creak as they pulled against the tide. The crew would moan and creak as they drank on her decks, and he would fall into unconsciousness in this old flenser’s hut. Here he was, shipwife in name only. Commander in word only. Failure.

Voice, you’re going to go with me here or not but it is a huge part of this book. Repetition and rhythm are part of it. But it’s also a tool. This is a world invented from the bottom up and there will be a lot of phrases and words that you don’t know. Some I’ll just leave you to work out but when it matters I will make sure you get a bit of a clue. So here I use repetition to tie together the ideas of “Shipwife” and “Commander,” so you know that’s an important position. Also, that our subject is clearly very bad at it at and he is feeling quite sorry for himself. He’s pretty weaksauce, to be honest. (Okay, There is some hand holding in the Scattered Archipelago.)

Voices from outside, because even here, in the long-abandoned and ghost-haunted flensing yards there was no real escape from others. Not even the memory of keyshan’s rot, the disease of the boneyards, could keep people from cutting through on occasion.

Shattered Stone came in this morran, said they saw an archeyex over Sleightholme. Sent their windtalker fell mad and it nearly wrecked ’em. Had to kill the creature to stop it bringing a wind to throw ’em across a lee shore.’

‘Aren’t been an archeyex seen for nigh on my lifetime. It brings nothing good, paint that on a rock for the Sea Hag.’ And the voices faded, lost in the hiss of the waves on the beach, eaten up by the sea as everything was destined to be, while he thought on what the sailorsaid – ‘brings nothing good’. May as well as say the sun will rise on the morran, for this is the Hundred Isles – when did the last good thing ever happen here?

WTF does any of that mean? It doesn’t really matter it’s just colour. I wanted to build this idea you are somewhere else — this is not our world, they don’t speak like us, they don’t have the same words or cadences. But you are hopefully left with the idea that whatever happened it’s not good and this is not a good place and that is enough for you right now. I am often writing to give you a feeling rather than definite information. Also, as this is not quite the version that appears in the finished books, the word ‘Sailor’ slipped through, which is a word that doesn’t exist in this world because they don’t use the word ‘sail’.  It’s really hard not using such familiar words but hopefully none slipped by. (They might have done though.)

The next voice he heard was a challenge. Delivered while he kept his eyes closed against the tides of nausea ebbing and flowing hot acidic waves from his stomach.

‘Give me your hat.’ A voice thick with the sea, a bird-shriek croak of command. The sort of voice you ran to obey, had you scurrying up the rigging to spread the wings of your ship. Maybe, just maybe, on any other day or after a single cup of wine, maybe he would have done what she said and handed over his two-tailed shipwife’s hat, which, along with the bright dye in his hair, marked him out as a commander – though an undeserving one.

But in the restless night his sleep had been troubled by thoughts of his father and thoughts of another life, not a better one, not an easier one, but a sober one, one without shame. One in which he did not feel the pull of the Sea Hag’s slimy hands trying to drag him down to his end. One of the long days at the sail of a flukeboat, pulling on the ropes as his father glowed with pride at how well his little fisher boy worked the wings. Of long days before his father’s strong and powerful body was broken as easily as a thin varisk vine, ground to meat between the side of his boat and the pitiless hull of a boneship. A hand reaching up from black water, a bearded face, mouth open as if to call to his boy in his final agonising second. Such strength, and it meant nothing.

So maybe he had, for once, woken with the idea of how wonderful it would be to have a little pride. And if there had been a day for him to give up the two-tailed hat of shipwife, then it was not this day.

Again, a lot of words we don’t know but used in ways that tell you what they are. Wings, not sails here. And I’ve tried to use words and names that feel like something (oh, hello synaesthesia). Archeyex, used earlier sounds spiky, it has its base in archeopterix. Flukeboat, of course, whales and dolphins have flukes (though they don’t exist in this world, I never said I was logical) later we have skeers, a kind of carrion eater and we have the arakeesians, and something about that name sound’s big and dangerous to me, but they shorten it to ‘keyshan cos that sounds like the sort of thing people would do.

And here we learn of a death as well. Grief is an intrinsic part of this book, as is that lesson about the fragility of life, how very delicate we are in what is a very hard a cruel world and that fear of damaging his body, and dying, is a huge part of this character. People who run into battle and be really cool cos they are great warriors aren’t that interesting to me, cos that’s not brave. People who go into a fight all too aware they are likely to die but still do it? It’s them I want to know about.

‘No,’ he said. He had to scrape the words out of his mind, and that was exactly how it felt, like he drew the curve of a curnow blade down the inside of his skull; words falling from his mouth slack as midtide. ‘I am shipwife of the Tide Child and this is my symbol of command.’ He touched the rim of the black two-tailed cap. ‘I am shipwife, and you will have to take this hat from me.’

How strange it felt to say those words, those fleet words that he knew more from his father’s stories of service than from any real experience. They were good words though, strong words with a history, and they felt right in his mouth. If he were to die then they were not bad final words for his father to hear from his place, deep below the sea, standing warm and welcome at the Hag’s eternal bonefire.

Casually drop in the first mention of the ship’s name, Tide Child, here. Like you do. That felt like a very shippy name, it also has resonance later on as you find things out about people.

He squinted at the figure before him. Thoughts fought in his aching head: which one of them had come for him? Since he’d become shipwife he knew a challenge must come. He commanded angry women and men, bad women and men, cruel women and men – and it had only ever been a matter of time before one of his crew wanted the hat and the colours. Was it Barlay who stood in the door hole of the bothy? She was a hard one, violent. But no, too small for her and the silhouette of this figure wore its hair long, not cut to the skull. Kanvey then? He was a man jealous of everything and everyone, and quick with his knife. But no, the silhouette appeared female, undoubtably so. No straight lines to her under the tight fishskin and feather. Cwell then? She would make a move, and she could swim so would have been able to get off the ship.

A list of people? Hmm, maybe these people are going to be important later on so…

He levered himself up, feeling the still unfamiliar tug of the curnow at his hip.

He is not a warrior.

‘We fight then,’ said the figure and she turned, walking out into the sun. Her hair worn long, grey and streaked in the colours of command: bright reds and blues. The sun scattered off the fishskin of her clothing, tightly wound about her muscled body and held in place with straps. Hanging from the straps were knives, small crossbows and a twisting shining jingling assortment of good-luck trinkets that spoke of a lifetime of service and violence. Around her shoulders hung a precious feathered cloak, and where the fishskin scattered the sunlight the feather cloak hoarded it, twinkling and sparkling, passing motes of light from plume to plume so each and every colour shone and shouted out its hue.

And we get a description of this unnamed woman. And she is clearly spectacular and special. And we learn about their materials and colours and way they dress, if they’re a bit fancy anyway, and she is clearly a bit fancy. She is as far from him AS CAN BE right now.

I am going to die, he thought.

Fair assumption, mate.

She idled away from the leaning bothy he had slept in, away from the small stinking abandoned dock, and he followed. No one was around. He had chosen this place for its relative solitude, amazed how easily it could be found; even on an isle as busy as Shipshulme people tended to flock together, to find each other, and of course they shunned such Hag-haunted places as this where the keyshan’s curse still slept.

I put in and took out, and put in and took out, this paragraph so many times. Cos earlier on we have those two people talking. So is it really lonely, RJ? Well, yes, it’s relative so… but… STOP OVERTHINKING IT. Okay. Also, notice as well there’s a lot of sea related language, a lot of bird related language is cropping up too. Cropping, bit of a pun there.

Maybe I could have cut this paragraph out bu… SHUT UP, RJ. IT’S TOO LATE NOW.

Along the shingle beach they walked: her striding, looking for a place, and him following like a lost kuwai, one of the flightless birds they bred for meat, looking for a flock to join. Though of course there was no flock for a man like him, only the certainty of the death that he walked towards.

She stood with her back to him as though he were not worth her attention. She tested the beach beneath her feet, pushing at the shingle with the toes of her high boots, as if searching for something under the stones that might rear up and bite her. He was reminded of himself as a child, checking the sand for jullwyrms before playing alone with a group of imaginary friends. Ever the outsider. Ach, he should have known it would come to this.

So full of self pity, and she has weighed him and judged him. Also, more bird words.

When she turned, he recognised her, knew her. Not socially and not through any action he had fought as he had fought none. But he knew her face – the pointed nose, the sharp cheekbones, the weathered skin, the black patterns drawn around her eyes and the scintillating golds and greens on her cheeks that marked her as someone of note. He recognised her, had seen her walking before prisoners. Seen her walking before children won from raids on the Gaunt Islands, children to be made ready for theThirteenbern’s priest’s thirsty blades, children to be sent to the Hag or to ride the bones of a ship. Seen her standing on the prow of her ship, Arakeesian Dread, named for the sea dragons that provided the bones for the ships and had once been cut apart on the beach below them. Named for the sea dragons that no longer came. Named for the sea dragons that were sinking into myth the way a body would eventually sink to the sea floor.

Yeah, they murder their own children for folkloric reasons, but everyone’s cool with that. Really, these people are awful. Also, SHE IS VERY SPECIAL, so fancy, right? And we learn there’s no more dragons. More repetition, this is the language of this place, it has the rhythm of the sea. Coming in, going out, the same thing going in circles. This idea is thematically important for the entire trilogy. Ooh, hark at me with my big words.

But oh that ship!

He’d seen that too.

Last of the five-ribbers he was, Arakeesian Dread. Eighteen bright corpselights dancing above him, a huge long-beaked arakeesian skull as long as a two-ribber crowned his prow, blank eyeholes staring out, his beak covered in metal to use as a ram. Twenty huge gallowbows on each side of the maindeck and many more standard bows below in the underdeck. A crew of over four hundred, which polished and shone every bone that made his frame, so he was blinding white against the sea.

Oh come on, ships made of dragon bones is cool, right? Although there’s a whole argument to be had about what a dragon is really…

He’d seen her training her crew, and he’d seen her fight. At a dock, over a matter of honour when someone mentioned the circumstances of her birth. It was not a long fight, and when asked for mercy, she showed none, and he did not think it was in her for she was Hundred Isles and fleet to the core. Cruel and hard.

Oh-oh. Looking bleak for our unnamed POV character.

What light there was in the sky darkened as if Skearith the god-bird closed its eye to his fate, the fierce heat of the air fleeing as did that small amount of hope that had been in his breast – that single fluttering possibility that he could survive. He was about to fight Meas Gilbryn, ‘Lucky’ Meas, the most decorated, the bravest, the fiercest shipwife the Hundred Isles had ever seen.

Seven pages in before we get the first character name and we still don’t know the other. This is VERY DELIBERATE.

He was going to die.

Well, I have been dropping hints that you’re well out of your depth, mate.

But why would Lucky Meas want his hat? Even as he prepared himself for death he could not stop his mind working. She could have any command she wanted. The only reason she would want his would be if…

And that was unthinkable.


Meas Gilbryn condemned to the black ships? Condemned to die? Sooner see an island get up and walk than that happen.

Had she been sent to kill him?

Maybe. There were those to whom his continued living was an insult. Maybe they had become bored with waiting?


‘What is your name?’ She croaked the words like something hungry for carrion.

He tried to speak, found his mouth dry and not merely from last night’s drink. Fear. Though he had walked with it as a companion for six months, this made it no less palatable.

He swallowed, licked his lips. ‘My name is Joron. Joron Twiner.’

This is one of those silly things that I thought a lot about but most people probably won’t notice. That’s not a slight, by the way. I’m not saying you don’t pay attention it’s just that maybe it’s a thing that’s only really there for your subconscious. But this is a book that is heading toward a big fight. A REALLY big fight. Joron, our main character, is broken. He’s nothing. So is Tide Child and so is the crew and this woman, Meas, has come to fix that. Joron, in a literal sense, doesn’t exist until she gives him permission to exist by asking for his name. Before that he’s a nothing to her and to us, just a voice. In a lot of ways he is the exact opposite of Girton from the Wounded Kingdom books who was a strong personality from the moment we met him. Joron is not. He has to become, and this is the moment it starts for him, and for Tide Child and for its crew. We are going on a longer, and harder journey this time.

‘Don’t know it,’ she said, dismissive, uninterested. ‘Not seen it written in the rolls of honour, not heard it in any reports of action.’

She is part of this world. He is not.

‘I never served before I was sent to the black ships,’ he said. She drew her blade. ‘I was a fisher once.’ Did he see a flash in her eyes, and if he did what could it mean? Annoyance, boredom?

‘And?’ she said, taking a practice swing with her heavy blade, contemptuous of him, barely even watching him. ‘How does a fisher get condemned to a ship of the dead? Never mind become a shipwife.’ Another practice slash at the innocent air before her.

‘I killed a man.’

She stared at him.

‘In combat,’ he added, and he had to swallow again, forcing a hard ball of cold-stone fear down his neck.

‘So you can fight.’ Her blade came up to ready. Light flashed down its length. Something was inscribed on it, no cheap slag-iron curnow like his own.

‘He was drunk and I was lucky,’ he said.

Ah, it is the humour.

‘Well, Joron Twiner, I am neither, despite my name,’ she said, eyes grey and cold. ‘Let’s get this over with, eh?’

He drew his own sword and went straight into a lunge. No warning, no niceties. He was not a fool and he was not soft. You did not live long in the Hundred Isles if you were soft. His only chance of beating Lucky Meas lay in surprising her. His blade leaped out, a single straight thrust for the gut. A simple, concise move he had practised a hundred thousand times in his life – for every woman and man of the Hundred Isles dreams of being in the fleet and using his sword to protect the islands’ children. It was a perfect move, untouched by his exhaustion and unsullied by a body palsied by lack of drink.

She knocked his blade aside with a twitch of her wrist, and the weighted end of the curving curnow blade dragged his sword outward, past her side. He stumbled forward, suddenly off balance. Her free hand came round, and he caught the shine of a stone ring on her knuckles and knew she wore a rockfist in the moment before it made contact with his temple.

He was on the ground. Looking up into the canopy of the wide and bright blue sky wondering where the clouds had gone. Waiting for the thrust that would finish him.

Her sword tip appeared in his line of sight.

Touched the skin of his forehead.

Raked a painful line up to his hair and pushed the hat from his head. She used her sword to flick his hat into the air and caught it, putting it on. She did not smile, showed no sense of triumph, only stared at him while the blood ran down his face and he waited for the end.

‘Never lunge with a curnow, Joron Twiner,’ she said quietly. ‘Did they teach you nothing? You slash with it. It is all it is fit for.’

Already teaching him. But we learn her style here. She’s very much show don’t tell. She’ll knock you down and tell you why and how, if you can get back up.

‘What poor final words for me,’ he said. ‘To die with another’s advice in my ear.’ Did something cross her face at that, some deeply buried remembrance of what it was to laugh? Or did she simply pity him?

Suck it up, Joron.

‘Why did they make you shipwife?’ she said. ‘You plain did not win rank in a fight.’

‘I—’ he began.

‘There are two types of ship of the dead.’ She leaned forward, the tip of her sword dancing before his face. ‘There is the type the crew run, with a weak shipwife who lets them drink themselves to death at the staystone. And there is the type a strong shipwife runs that raises his wings for trouble and lets his women and men die well.’ He could not take his eyes from the tip of the blade, Meas a blur behind the weapon. ‘It seems to me the Tide Child has been the first, but now you will lead me to him and he will try what it is to be the second.’

Total opposite of him. No doubt. No worry. Utterly confident. Of course, for story telling purposes, she can’t always be that, because that is dull. But here we present the outside of people, as the books goes on we drill further into them.

Joron opened his mouth to tell her she was wrong about him and his ship, but he did not because she was not.

‘Get up, Joron Twiner,’ she said. ‘You’ll not die today on this hot and long-blooded sand. You’ll live to spend your blood in service to the Hundred Isles along with every other on that ship. Now come, we have work to do.’ She turned, sheathing her sword, as sure he would do as she asked as she was Skearith’s Eye would rise in the morning and set at night.

The shingle moved beneath him as he rose, and anger stirred within him. Anger at this woman who had taken his command from him. Who had called him weak and treated him with such contempt. She was just like every other who was lucky enough to be born whole of body and of the strong. Sure of their place, blessed by the Sea Hag, the Maiden and the Mother and ready to trample any other before them to get what they wanted. The criminal crew of Tide Child, he understood them at least. They were rough, fierce and had lived with no choice but to watch out for themselves. But her and her kind? They trampled others for joy.

Class war, brother Joron!

She had taken his hat of command from him, and though he had never wanted it before, it had suddenly come to mean something. Her actions had awoken something in him.

He intended to get it back.



And from here we move on. And there’s a lot we need to know, these ships are big and have a lot of crew: we need to meet them, understand them and understand how the ship works. Bit by bit I drip in more about the world and more about the people until we get to the point that, when it matters, you no longer have to think about the words and we, like Tide Child, are flying through the story. So stick around for the ride.


RJ Barker’s The Bone Ships is out this week, published by Orbit Books in the UK and North America. His first trilogy, the Wounded Kingdom, is also out now, published by Orbit Books (UK/North America).

Also on CR: Interview with RJ Barker (2017); Reviews of Age of Assassins, Blood of Assassins, and King of Assassins

Follow the Author: Website, Goodreads, Twitter

One thought on “Annotated Excerpt: THE BONE SHIPS by RJ Barker (Orbit)

  1. This was fantastic. Both the extract of the book and the discussion of the process.

    So I’ve pre-ordered the novel. Because I don’t have enough things on my TBR pile. Or perhaps I have so many that one more won’t make much difference lol

    Thanks : )


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s